Multiple Meanings
It's weird that when we write things or say things, in our mind we
have a specific meaning; something that we are trying to convey to others. A
thought we are trying to get out. There comes an unfortunate time when our
words get taken out of context and mean something else to others. We say one
thing and in the end it means something completely different.
What we have to say is important. Having our thoughts deciphered
poorly can end up with miscommunications and hurt feelings or worse. That's
what happened at Romeo High School, just north of Detroit.
Many of us have had a biology where we learned about genes; genotypes
and phenotypes and all that jazz. Lecture after lecture we were always bored; resulting
in lack of understanding. Teachers always did their best to keep us involved
and engaged. Silly questions and worksheets that always got a few laughs. Some
laughs are better than none, right? The only problem with trying to be
creative is that sometimes we lose the true meaning, or point, behind a series
of words that make a problem.
At Romeo High school, students were given a homework question that
said, "The sister of the mom above also had issues with finding out who
the father of her baby was. She had the state take a blood test of potential
fathers. Based on the information in this table, why was the baby taken away by
the state after the test?” One father was outraged. He refused to have his
daughter do the assignment and sent it in with a letter attached saying, “We
teach our children not to sleep around.”
Not the best wording for an educational question. This question
leads the reader to think multiple things. Thoughts like why did the state take
the baby? Why are those the options for the father? These thoughts take away
from the educational purpose of the question.
(Options for potential father on take home assignment)
The options for the father are outrageous. Not only does it make
this women seem like a slut but it creates an image that women with a child (if
not married) sleep around with trashy men.
As a female, I’m outraged by this question. But as a teacher, I
can understand that the intent behind the question was good. That’s the problem
with words. Everyone interprets them differently. If we aren’t careful about
our word choice we can hurt someone. I do have to agree though. There are about
15 other ways that this question can be written that doesn’t degrade women and
send the wrong message.
The intent behind the question was to get the students thinking
about blood types but in the end students were thinking about how having a baby
will result in getting it taken away by the state.
Remember that regardless of what you mean, your words are open to
interpretation. Good or Bad.
For more information click below
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/02/15/we-teach-our-children-not-to-sleep-around-dad-outraged-over-biology-homework-that-stepped-way-way-over-the-line/
No comments:
Post a Comment